Will You Rather (2012)

Would You Rather is a 2012 American psychological horror film directed by David Guy Levy. Starring Brittany Snow and Jeffrey Combs, the film centers around a disturbing and twisted game that tests the limits of morality and human endurance. With its dark premise and intense atmosphere, Would You Rather is a chilling exploration of the lengths people will go to for money and survival, making it a standout film in the psychological horror genre.

The story follows Iris (Brittany Snow), a young woman struggling to take care of her sick brother, whom she can barely afford to treat. In a desperate attempt to gain financial assistance, she is invited to a dinner party hosted by a wealthy philanthropist, Shepard Lambrick (Jeffrey Combs). At the dinner, she and several other guests are forced to participate in a twisted game of “Would You Rather,” where they must make life-altering choices that often involve intense physical and psychological pain. As the game progresses, the stakes get higher, and the guests are pushed to their limits.

Would You Rather delves into the psychological effects of extreme pressure and human vulnerability. The film explores themes of desperation, morality, and survival, highlighting the choices individuals are forced to make when faced with life-or-death situations. The dinner party setting, combined with the rules of the game, creates an intense atmosphere of fear and discomfort. The film’s storytelling builds tension effectively, allowing the audience to feel the mounting dread as the charactersโ€™ decisions grow increasingly horrific.


The characters in Would You Rather are multi-dimensional, with each guest representing different facets of desperation and survival instincts. Iris, the protagonist, is portrayed as a woman who is initially motivated by the desire to save her brother but slowly becomes more morally conflicted as the game intensifies. Shepard Lambrick, played by Jeffrey Combs, is a cold and manipulative figure who orchestrates the game for his own amusement. The interactions between the characters reveal how far each person is willing to go when faced with unspeakable choices, with some characters revealing hidden cruelty, while others show resilience and empathy.


David Guy Levyโ€™s direction in Would You Rather creates an atmosphere of claustrophobia and dread. The cinematography makes use of tight spaces and lingering shots to amplify the tension during the game. The setting of the lavish but dark mansion contrasts with the brutality of the game, adding to the psychological unease. The pacing of the film builds progressively, allowing the horror to unfold in a slow, torturous manner that keeps the audience on edge. The visual style complements the filmโ€™s dark themes and intensifies the emotional impact of the unfolding horror.


In conclusion, Would You Rather is a gripping psychological horror film that examines human nature under extreme circumstances. With its intense plot, disturbing themes, and well-developed characters, the film offers a thought-provoking exploration of morality and survival. While not for the faint of heart, Would You Rather is an effective thriller that keeps viewers engaged and unsettled, offering a haunting reminder of the dark places desperation can lead. It remains a memorable addition to the psychological horror genre, with its unsettling premise and intense atmosphere.